Showing posts with label GunViolence. Show all posts
Showing posts with label GunViolence. Show all posts

Saturday, April 4, 2009

Do Guns Make Us Safer?

I support Second Amendment rights, but I also support strenuous gun control. Recently, I engaged in an argument with a friend regarding gun rights. My friend attacked college campus gun bans, and his argument ran like this: Perpetrators of gun violence only shoot up locales that lack guns (like college campuses); thus we should allow guns everywhere, because such a policy would decrease shooting rampages; and finally, the existence of more guns at more locales would not increase violence because permit & licensing laws limit possession to the responsible citizens among us.

There are many flaws with this argument, but I will consider only one here -- my friend's suggestion that the permit process curtails gun-related violence enough to justify permitting guns on campuses and other non-carry spots.

First, this argument presumes that the permit process is strenuous; it is not. Second, this argument wrongly presumes that permit- and license-holders must renew their permit/license so frequently that the renewal process will revoke permits/licenses from those that are initially sane but that soon turn crazy. Third, this argument fails to understand that even the most sane among us can make serious, serious errors, and that such serious errors will be amplified if Americans are allowed to carry guns around all the time, no matter the locale. Fourth, this argument inappropriately assumes it is possible to test for the type of crazy that brings about gun rampages; after all, will permit testers conduct a psychological exam on applicants? The gun lobby would never allow it!

Point in case: The New York Times reports that the shooter at the Immigration Center in NY yesterday (04.03.09) "had a New York State pistol license that listed two pistols, a 45-caliber Beretta and a 9-mm Beretta." The shooter killed thirteen.